16

May
LinkedIn
X
Facebook
Innovation Gadfly Bite the Beast Until it Moves
  • Home
  • New
  • Property Rights
  • Courts
  • Legislation
  • Corruption
  • About
  • Submissions
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
☰
Innovation Gadfly
Subscribe
Submit Article
Advertise
Home > New
1,168 views 4 min 0 Comment

Ironman Has Taken A Bite Out Of The Apple

Molly Metz - January 16, 2024
Masimo vs apple

In the Spring of 2023, I met Joe Kiani, an inventor and owner of Masimo. I flew from Denver to Orange County with the one intention of sharing my story with Joe and with Congressman Correa. Little did I know I was about to meet my biggest hero.

The Masimo building is a spectacle! The big glass windows and dramatic entry way make you feel like you are in a movie! I was later told that the Masimo building was used in the popular movie “Ironman!” How poetic! 

That day I sat in a large conference room. Gathered at the table was Joe, his attorneys, Rep Correa, his assistant, and a few others. Joe proceeded to tell his story. I couldn’t believe my ears. Joe was telling a story so similar to mine it was like hearing my own story! His story involved a possible and exciting partnership with Apple, then Apple deceiving him, stealing his employees and his IP, leaving Joe with the option of walking away with his tail between his legs, or option of fighting. Joe fought, like I did. But unlike myself, Joe was surviving. 

That day when I told my similar IPR experience I told it with a new sense of confidence and feeling of being understood. Joe went through this too. I didn’t feel alone, and I didn’t feel stupid anymore. 

Joe started his company, pre-AIA. He has expressed socially how this is attributed to the growth of his company. Patent law “worked” prior to 2012. What he means by that is simple. When an infringer stole your IP prior to the America Invents Act of 2011, the patent owner was able to get a day in court. A day in court means there is a judge, a jury, due process, witness testimony and at one-point injunctive relief−before the 2006 Supreme Court Decision, eBay vs MercExchange. This provided a fair process for both parties.

Joe was able to build a strong foundation for Masimo because of this. Unfortunately for a lot of start-ups like mine that started their companies closer to 2012, they did not have the opportunity Joe did with IP protection. 

Since 2012 Joe has been fighting Apple. He has spent over 12 million dollars defending his patents and unjustly losing his patents to Apple. Joe has something I didn’t have, nor do most start-ups. He has a patent portfolio and financial backing to “play this game.” So does Apple. Joe has something Apple doesn’t: integrity and 80,000 US Inventor members on his side. 

Joe’s fight right now is lighting a huge fire underneath me and thousands of other inventors in this country. This can cause a tsunami against large corporations that have a history of squashing the little guys. 

Small inventors who have lost their patents have no fight in this game, but they have a voice and the spirit to be with Joe in this fight. Joe, you are Ironman right now. You have taken the courage to take a bite of the Apple.  We are all in debt to you.

Show your support to Joe by joining inventors and small business owners on January 17th. Joe will be telling his story on a zoom call. It is free to join, but you must register soon! 

Date: Wednesday, January 17th, 2024

Time: 5pm ET; 4pm CT; 3pm MT; 2pm PT

REGISTER: https://us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_BKV4Eq3UTuGkXeiGEzKHGQ

Molly Metz
+ posts
  • Molly Metz
    https://innovationgadfly.com/author/molly-metz/
    The Great Equalizer: Reflecting on My Role in Award-Winning Film
  • Molly Metz
    https://innovationgadfly.com/author/molly-metz/
    USPTO Obviousness Guidance: An Opportunity for Inventors
  • Molly Metz
    https://innovationgadfly.com/author/molly-metz/
    US Inventor Sues USPTO to Ensure Patents Reflect the Law 
  • Molly Metz
    https://innovationgadfly.com/author/molly-metz/
    Clear and Convincing: Will changing the standard save America’s greatest patents?
Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

PREVIOUS

China, the Once Great Silicon Valley, and the Petri Dish Effect

NEXT

What Is The Outlook For American Manufacturing For 2024
Related Post
patent death
January 25, 2024
The Death of a Canary: Part One 
September 20, 2024
Mossoff Shows the RESTORE Act Codifies eBay Factors
ptab fair unfair
January 23, 2024
Balancing the Scales: The Imperative of a Strong – but Fair – Patent System for Small Businesses and Independent Inventors
PTAB hinders innovation threats national security
May 14, 2024
Dear Congress, the PTAB Hinders Innovation and Threatens National Security

Recent Posts

  • Time to Turn the US Rejection Office Back into the US Patent Office – Part 1
  • Why Patent Reform Is Urgent: How China Exploits U.S. Disclosures and Undermines Innovation
  • Weaponized Fairness: Big Tech’s Dirty Secret in the U.S. Patent System
  • How Big Tech Used the Supreme Court to Kill Competition
  • China’s Warm Water Port is the U.S. Supreme Court

Recent Comments

  1. Johan C Fitter on Time to Turn the US Rejection Office Back into the US Patent Office – Part 1
  2. Michael E. Zall on Time to Turn the US Rejection Office Back into the US Patent Office – Part 1
  3. Julie Burke on Time to Turn the US Rejection Office Back into the US Patent Office – Part 1
  4. kassidy morinville on US Inventor Sues USPTO to Ensure Patents Reflect the Law 
  5. Johan C Fitter on US Inventor Sues USPTO to Ensure Patents Reflect the Law 

Categories

  • Business
  • Copyright
  • Corruption
  • Courts
  • Featured
  • Legislation
  • Litigation
  • New
  • Patents
  • Politics
  • Popular
  • Property Rights
  • PTAB
  • Trending
  • Uncategorized
  • USPTO
Innovation Gadfly
Gadfly Philosophy


Innovation Gadfly exists to disrupt corruption and the resulting unequal treatment favoring the large over the small that exists in America’s innovation economy. We strive to give the small guys a loud voice. Innovation Gadfly will bite the beast until it moves.

Information
  • Submissions
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • About Us

BITE THE BEAST UNTIL IT MOVES

About

Innovation drives our nation’s success. For far too long, our country’s small businesses, innovators, and entrepreneurs have been neglected and silenced. Innovation Gadfly publishes articles covering various innovation-related topics in support of small guys and sheds light on the corruption that exists in our nation today.

Subscribe
Copyright 2024 - InnovationGadfly.com. All Rights Reserved.